Home » Ethics » Gardasil and Government Vaccine Requirements

Gardasil and Government Vaccine Requirements

The recent storm about Gardasil (the vaccine to prevent some types of cervical cancer, sometimes spelled Gardisil) being mandated by the government misses the real issue. It’s not about being untested, or the cost. The real issue is why should this be forced onto citizens?

Several points have come up in the debate. First, it’s all about money for the drug company. Of course it is, that’s why they’re in business. You can’t blame a company for wanting to make money any more than a dog for eating — it’s their nature. Second, it’s untested. True, but at some point all medical advances were untested. Lastly, it’s expensive. Also true, and if mandated by the government, it could be a burden for many families. We won’t enter in to the debate on it’s effectiveness, or it’s safety — that’s for other people.

Some are against it as (they claim) it could lead to more young people engaging in risky sexual behaviors, and more teenage pregnancies (which appear to be fashionable now for 14-year-olds — an entirely separate issue which needs to be addressed). That may (or may not) be true, but that argument also misses the main issue.

The missing issue is simple: why should this be mandatory? Let’s assume for argument it’s 100% safe, and 100% effective (neither are bound to be true). The government still should not require it. Why not if it’s safe and effective? Because no overwhelming need exists. Governments are instituted to protect freedoms, not restrict them. Certainly, in the event of some communicable diseases society has a need to protect people as a group, but that’s not the issue here.

Cancer isn’t contagious, so no overwhelming society need is served by requiring it. Thus, such decisions should be left up to citizens themselves. Unfortunately, lost in all the static of this debate is the fact governments should not restrict the rights of citizens on a whim, even if the intention is good.

Gardisil may be a good idea, and if all the claims are true, it appears to be something people should seriously consider, but required? Nope. That goes against the freedoms governments should protect.

Personal responsibility falls on individuals, not the government.

Advertisements

2 Comments

  1. laevern says:

    Government would require a medicine if their was an overwhelming need.HPV Vaccine is no overwhelming need does put up debate that it is being mandated.
    1/no history of man or animal developing acquired immunity before making the vaccine, this acquired immunity is the bases of a true working vaccine
    2/vaccines are made of the weaker stain not the four most dangerous.small pox- cow pox,why induce the high risk.
    3/The vaccine virus is partially alive so the body fights it and in turn learns the acquired immunty of never getting it again.

    If the HPV vaccine was infecting with HPV it would not be immediate symptoms as with a virus has symptoms. HPV symptoms do sound alot like those side effects they keep talking about. Side effects go away and do not get worse.

    Garasil their is another spelling of Garasil in other languages.The HPV Vaccine. Those whose job it is to do something are not?????where are they

  2. HSIAlert says:

    Important Video on the Potential Dangers of Gardasil

    Please take a few minutes and watch this important video on the potential dangers –and limited benefits–of the Gardasil vaccine and consider sharing it with others. At least thirty two girls have already died.

    Please share this with anyone you know who may be considering the vaccine for their daughters or themselves.

    Thank you so much!

    http://www.hsibaltimore.com/sign-up-today/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: